Three Door Puzzle

In this gameshow, you are confronted by a set of three closed doors:

Behind two of the doors is nothing, and behind one of the doors is a cash prize:

Each time you play the game, the door that the prize is behind will be chosen randomly by the gameshow host.

Your task is to pick the door which has the prize behind it.

To add some interest to the game, it will proceed as follows:
1. The gameshow host will place the prize (randomly) behind one of the doors (ie. the host knows which door the prize is behind)
2. The gameshow host will ask you to pick a door.
3. The gameshow host will then open one of the other doors so that you are only left with two unopened doors. The host will make sure he never opens a door which has the prize behind it.
4. The gameshow host will then give you the chance to either keep your original selection, or allow you to change to the other door which is left unopened.

The question is, what do you do?
Is it
(a) Better to keep your original choice?
(b) Better to change to the other door?
(c) Doesn't matter what you do, since it's still a random pick and the prize could be behind either of the two doors?

In other words, the question is:

Both probabilities may, of course, be the same.

Think about the problem for a while before you look at the answer, as it may surprise you!



Try it for yourself

Click the link below to try playing the game yourself. Pick a strategy and stick to it for at least 10 or more times with each strategy. You'll see the answer to the question above. You'll also see a practical example of the fact that 'probability theory' only holds if you perform enough trials.

(NOTE: The game requires a forms-capable browser. If, during the game, you get a message from your browser saying "No data in document", just reload the page (and repost the fields, if asked) until you get a full page.)



Go to:



Mail to: sky@intergalact.com
© Copyright Sky Coyote, 1995.

Last updated: 6/29/95